People & Stories

Failing forward: famous setbacks that came before success

Behind many well known success stories sits a failure that could have ended them. Five documented setbacks, and a practical way to make your own failures useful.

By the trevisia editors31 October 20265 min read

A desk with crumpled sketches and a cardboard prototype under a lampAI generated

In July 1923, a 21-year-old animator in Kansas City watched his first company go bankrupt. Walt Disney sold his camera, which raised enough for a one-way train ticket to California, and took an unfinished reel of film with him. Before the year was out, he and his brother Roy had started a new studio in Hollywood.

Stories like this are told so often that they risk becoming a cliché: fail, persist, triumph. The truth is less tidy and more useful. Setbacks do not lead to success automatically, and most people who fail never become famous. What the best documented cases show is how people responded. The accounts below rely on the people's own words and reliable reporting; trevisia did not interview them.

Walt Disney: two losses before Mickey

Laugh-O-Gram Films, incorporated in Kansas City in 1922, made short cartoons. A distributor that had promised about $11,000 for a series of six films paid only a $100 advance before going bankrupt itself, and later projects did not bring in enough to keep going. The studio filed for bankruptcy in July 1923.

The second blow came in 1928. Disney's popular character Oswald the Lucky Rabbit belonged to Universal, not to him. When he tried to negotiate a better fee, his distributor Charles Mintz demanded a cut instead and had already hired away several of his animators. Disney lost both the character and much of his team. His answer was a new character he would own himself: Mickey Mouse, who appeared later that year. The lesson was practical: keep the rights to what you create.

James Dyson: 5,127 attempts

Dyson's bagless vacuum cleaner is often told as a story of genius. By his own account it was a story of repetition: around five years and 5,127 prototypes, each a variation on the last, before the design worked. Every failed version told him something the previous one had not.

Even then, the setbacks continued, because the major manufacturers would not take the design up. How he responded is one of the stories in five founders, five turning points.

J. K. Rowling: a dozen rejections

In her 2008 commencement speech at Harvard, J. K. Rowling described where she stood seven years after graduating: her marriage had ended, she was a single parent without a job and, in her own description, about as poor as anyone could be in modern Britain without being homeless. She was writing the first Harry Potter book.

The manuscript is widely reported to have been turned down by twelve publishers before Bloomsbury, then a small British publisher, accepted it. Harry Potter and the Philosopher's Stone appeared in 1997, when Rowling was 31. In the same speech she argued that failure had stripped away everything inessential and left her free to put all her energy into the work that mattered to her. In her words: “And so rock bottom became the solid foundation on which I rebuilt my life.”

Steve Jobs: pushed out of his own company

In 1985, after a power struggle with chief executive John Sculley and the board, Steve Jobs lost his role running the Macintosh group at Apple, the company he had co-founded. He resigned that September, aged 30. He went on to found NeXT, a computer company, and in 1986 paid $10 million for the computer graphics group spun out of Lucasfilm that became Pixar. Pixar released Toy Story in 1995.

In December 1996 Apple agreed to buy NeXT, and in September 1997 Jobs was named interim chief executive. In his 2005 commencement address at Stanford, he said that although it had been devastating at the time, being fired from Apple turned out to be the best thing that could have happened to him, because it let him start again as a beginner. That is his reading in hindsight, twenty years later, not how it felt in 1985.

Howard Schultz: 217 noes

In 1983, a buying trip to Milan convinced Howard Schultz, then head of retail operations and marketing at Starbucks, a small Seattle coffee bean seller, that Americans would love Italian-style espresso bars. The owners were not persuaded, so in 1985 he left to start his own. In his book Pour Your Heart Into It, Schultz recalls that of the 242 potential investors he approached, 217 said no.

Enough said yes. His first Il Giornale coffee bar opened in Seattle in 1986, and in 1987 he and his investors bought Starbucks' retail business for $3.8 million. The rejections did not mean the idea was bad. They meant he had to keep asking until he found the people who shared his view.

PersonSetbackAge at the timeWhat came next
Walt DisneyLaugh-O-Gram bankrupt, 192321A new studio in Hollywood the same year
James Dyson5,127 prototypes, late 1970s to early 1980sIn his thirtiesThe G-Force in Japan, then DC01 in 1993
J. K. RowlingRejected by a dozen publishers, mid-1990sAbout 30Bloomsbury publishes the first book in 1997
Steve JobsLeaves Apple, 198530NeXT, Pixar and a return to Apple in 1997
Howard Schultz217 investors say no, 1985 to 1986Early thirtiesBuys Starbucks in 1987

Ages calculated from published birth dates. Sources listed below.

What setbacks teach, and what they do not

It is tempting to draw a simple moral: fail often enough and you will succeed. The stories above do not support that. What they show is narrower and more practical:

  • Separate the verdict from the data. Rejection letters were opinions about one manuscript, not a judgement on Rowling's ability to write.
  • Fix what you can control. After losing Oswald, Disney made sure he owned his next character.
  • Make failure cheap. Dyson's prototypes were small, quick tests, not bets of everything he had.
  • Count the noes as part of the process. Schultz needed a great many conversations to find his investors.
  • Respect the cost. Bankruptcy, poverty and losing your job are painful, and nobody should seek them out for the sake of character.

Setbacks do not lead to success automatically. What they can do is teach, if you let them.

That last point matters. Glorifying failure can push people into reckless risks, or make them feel ashamed when a setback does not turn into a triumph. Most setbacks simply have to be absorbed, learned from and survived, and steady routines help more than heroics; see why habits beat willpower. For many people the comeback also comes later in life, as our piece on career changes after 40 shows.

The CV of failures

In 2016, Johannes Haushofer, then an assistant professor of psychology and public affairs at Princeton University, posted an unusual document online: a CV listing the programmes, jobs, fellowships and grants he had not got, and papers that journals had rejected. He wrote that most of what he tried failed, but that his failures were invisible while his successes were visible, which could leave others blaming themselves for their own setbacks. He credited the idea to an article by the scientist Melanie Stefan in the journal Nature.

The document spread widely. Haushofer later added a wry final entry noting that his CV of failures had received far more attention than his entire body of academic work.

Sources

  1. Laugh-O-Gram Studio, Wikipedia
  2. J. K. Rowling says she succeeded by breaking rules, not following them, CNBC, 2019
  3. Text of J. K. Rowling's speech, Harvard Gazette, 2008
  4. Steve Jobs, Wikipedia
  5. Howard Schultz, Wikipedia
  6. Sharing the failures, Inside Higher Ed, 2016

Questions and answers

Good to know

Was J. K. Rowling really rejected by twelve publishers?

Twelve is the figure most widely reported for the rejections before Bloomsbury accepted the first Harry Potter manuscript. Exact counts of rejections are hard to verify independently, so treat it as an approximate number rather than a precise record.

What is a CV of failures?

A list of the applications, projects and plans that did not work out, set out like a normal CV. Princeton researcher Johannes Haushofer made the idea famous in 2016, crediting an earlier article by Melanie Stefan in Nature. It helps make setbacks visible and normal.

Why did Steve Jobs leave Apple in 1985?

After disagreements with chief executive John Sculley, the board backed Sculley and Jobs lost his operating role. He resigned in September 1985, founded NeXT and bought what became Pixar. He returned when Apple bought NeXT and became interim chief executive in 1997.

Is failure necessary for success?

No. Many successful people had smooth starts, and many who fail never succeed later. Setbacks are common rather than required. What matters is how you respond: learning from them, keeping the cost of each attempt bearable and trying again in a better way.

The trevisia letter. One idea, one number, one next step.

Subscribe

Keep reading

More from People & Stories