Success & Mindset

Better decisions: a practical toolkit for clear choices

Most decisions deserve less agonising than they get, and a few deserve far more. These tools help you tell them apart and choose with a clear head.

By the trevisia editors31 October 20265 min read

A hand moving a knight on a wooden chess board in window lightAI generated

You probably make dozens of decisions before lunch without noticing, then spend weeks circling a single one: the job offer, the move, the business idea. Better decisions start with a question most people skip. How much attention does this choice actually deserve? The tools below range from a quick sorting question to a full weighted matrix. Use as many of them as the decision is worth, and no more.

Sort first: one-way and two-way doors

In his letter to Amazon shareholders for 2015, published in April 2016, Jeff Bezos split decisions into two types. Type 1 decisions are consequential and irreversible or nearly so. He called them one-way doors, and they deserve slow, careful deliberation. Type 2 decisions can be changed or reversed. These two-way doors, he argued, should be made quickly by individuals or small groups with good judgement.

His warning was that growing organisations tend to put many Type 2 decisions through the heavy Type 1 process. The result is slowness, excessive caution and less experimentation. In his letter for the following year he added that most decisions should probably be made with about 70 percent of the information you wish you had, because waiting for 90 percent usually means being slow.

The same logic applies to your own life. Buying a flat, having a child or leaving a secure job are closer to one-way doors. Trying a course, a new routine or a side project are two-way doors. Many decisions can also be redesigned to become reversible: rent before you buy, take a sabbatical before you resign, or test a business idea with a first client before you hand in your notice.

Set a deadline and reduce the options

Open-ended decisions expand to fill the time available. Give every decision that matters a date: a day or two for a two-way door, a few weeks for a one-way door, together with a short list of the information you still need. When the date arrives, decide with what you have. A useful formula is: I will decide by this date, after I have found out these things. For a job offer, that might mean deciding by Friday, after speaking to two people who work there and trying the commute at rush hour.

Reducing options can help too, although the research is more mixed than its reputation. A famous study published in 2000 by Sheena Iyengar and Mark Lepper found that shoppers offered 6 jams were far more likely to buy than those offered 24. Yet a 2010 meta-analysis by Benjamin Scheibehenne and colleagues, covering 50 experiments with 5,036 participants, found an average choice overload effect of virtually zero, with large differences between studies. Too much choice seems to hurt in some situations, not in all.

The practical lesson is modest: define your must-haves first, drop every option that fails them and compare the two or three serious candidates in depth.

Run a pre-mortem

The decision researcher Gary Klein described the pre-mortem in Harvard Business Review in 2007. Instead of asking what might go wrong, you imagine that the project has already failed and ask why. The shift makes it easier for quiet doubters to speak up, and Klein draws on earlier research on so-called prospective hindsight, which suggests that treating an outcome as certain helps people come up with more explanations for it. For a personal decision, it works like this:

  1. Describe the decision as if you had made it a year ago.
  2. Imagine it has turned out badly: not a little disappointing, but clearly a mistake.
  3. Spend five minutes writing down every reason why it failed, without discussion.
  4. If others are involved, collect one reason from each person in turn until the list is complete.
  5. Mark the two or three most likely reasons and change your plan to prevent them, or decide that the risk is acceptable.

Change the time frame with 10/10/10

The author Suzy Welch popularised a simple test in her 2009 book of the same name: how will you feel about this decision in 10 minutes, in 10 months and in 10 years? The question separates short-term discomfort from long-term consequences.

Asking for a pay rise is a good example. In 10 minutes, it feels awkward. In 10 months, you may be earning more, or at least know where you stand. In 10 years, you will hardly remember the awkward moment, but you might remember not asking. The test does not decide for you. It stops a passing feeling from casting the deciding vote. It is especially helpful when guilt or fear of conflict is involved, for example when you want to say no to a request or end a commitment that no longer fits.

Weigh what matters with a decision matrix

When several factors pull in different directions, a weighted decision matrix makes your priorities visible. List your criteria, give each a weight so that the weights add up to 100, score every option from 1 to 5 on each criterion, multiply each score by its weight and add up the results. Keep the list short, five to seven criteria are plenty, and set the weights before you score anything, so that you are not tempted to tune them in favour of the option you already like.

Imagine you have a job offer and three realistic options: stay in your current role, accept the offer, or stay and build a side project in the evenings.

Criterion (weight)StayNew offerStay plus side project
Income (30)3 (0.90)5 (1.50)3 (0.90)
Learning and growth (25)2 (0.50)4 (1.00)4 (1.00)
Time and flexibility (20)3 (0.60)2 (0.40)2 (0.40)
Security (15)5 (0.75)3 (0.45)4 (0.60)
Commute and daily stress (10)3 (0.30)2 (0.20)3 (0.30)
Weighted total3.053.553.20

Hypothetical example. Scores from 1 (poor) to 5 (excellent). Weighted value in brackets is score × weight ÷ 100, so totals stay on the same 1 to 5 scale.

Here the new offer wins. Now test how robust that is. If you shift the weights towards time (income 15, growth 20, time 35, security 20, commute 10), staying scores 3.20 and both other options score 3.05. The winner changes, which tells you that the real question is how much you value your time compared with your income.

If the result feels wrong, neither ignore the feeling nor obey it blindly. Usually a criterion is missing or a weight is off, and finding out which is the most valuable part of the exercise. The trevisia Decision Matrix does the arithmetic for you.

A note on decision fatigue

You may have read that every decision drains a limited supply of willpower, so you should save yours for what matters. This idea, known as ego depletion, became popular in the late 1990s and is now contested. In a registered replication published in 2016, 23 laboratories with 2,141 participants found an effect close to zero (d = 0.04). Some researchers argue that the evidence is inconclusive rather than settled either way.

The sensible conclusion is not to build your life around the theory. It is still practical to make important choices when you are rested and unhurried, because few people think at their best when they are exhausted or rushed.

Most decisions are doors you can walk back through, so walk through them.

Once you have chosen, turn the decision into action: a goal, a first step and an if-then plan, as described in goals that last. And if you want to see how others handled their biggest choices, read about five founders and their turning points.

Sources

  1. Letter to Shareholders for 2015, Jeff Bezos, Amazon (SEC filing), 2016
  2. 2016 Letter to Shareholders, Jeff Bezos, Amazon, 2017
  3. Performing a Project Premortem, Gary Klein, Harvard Business Review, 2007
  4. When choice is demotivating: can one desire too much of a good thing?, Iyengar and Lepper, Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 2000
  5. Can There Ever Be Too Many Options? A Meta-Analytic Review of Choice Overload, Scheibehenne, Greifeneder and Todd, Journal of Consumer Research, 2010
  6. A Multilab Preregistered Replication of the Ego-Depletion Effect, Hagger and colleagues, Perspectives on Psychological Science, 2016

Questions and answers

Good to know

How do I know whether a decision is reversible?

Ask what it would cost to undo it in six months: money, time, reputation and relationships. If the cost is small, treat it as a two-way door and decide quickly. If undoing it would be expensive or impossible, slow down and use the fuller toolkit.

What if the decision matrix contradicts my gut feeling?

Treat the gap as information. Check whether a criterion is missing or a weight is wrong, then run the matrix again. If your gut still disagrees, write down why, because that reason is often the criterion you left out.

Is decision fatigue real?

The broader idea that self-control runs out like fuel is contested, and a large multi-lab replication in 2016 found an effect close to zero. Being tired or rushed can still make careful thinking harder, so schedule important choices for a calm moment.

How long should a big decision take?

As long as it takes to gather the information that could change your mind, and no longer. Set a deadline, list the open questions and decide when the date arrives, even if you have only around 70 percent of what you wish you knew.

The trevisia letter. One idea, one number, one next step.

Subscribe

Keep reading

More from Success & Mindset