Success & Mindset

Redefining success: how do you really want to live?

Many of us chase a definition of success we never chose. Here is what long-term research says about a good life, and how to write a definition that is truly yours.

By the trevisia editors31 October 20265 min read

A lone walker on a winding path up a misty hill at sunriseAI generated

Most of us inherit a definition of success long before we are old enough to question it. Good grades, a respected job title, a bigger home, the next promotion. None of these are bad aims. The trouble starts when they become the only scoreboard, and you realise years later that you have been playing a game someone else designed.

The borrowed scoreboard

A borrowed definition of success is easy to spot once you look for it. It is measured in things other people can see: salary bands, car models, holiday photos. It moves every time you reach it, because the people you compare yourself with move too. And it rarely asks what your days actually feel like.

A personal definition works differently. It starts with how you want to spend your time, who you want to spend it with and what you want to be able to say about your work. Money and status can be part of it, but as tools rather than the target. That shift may sound soft. The research on what makes lives go well suggests it is anything but.

What the longest study of adult life found

In 1938, researchers at Harvard began following 268 sophomores to learn what helps people thrive. A second group of 456 men who grew up in inner-city Boston neighbourhoods later became part of the same project, and the research has since expanded to their children. Today the Harvard Study of Adult Development is directed by the psychiatrist Robert Waldinger, with Marc Schulz as associate director. Their 2023 book The Good Life draws on more than eight decades of data.

The headline finding is about relationships. The people who were most satisfied in their relationships at 50 were the healthiest at 80, and relationship satisfaction in midlife predicted later physical health better than cholesterol levels did. Waldinger has compared the harm of loneliness to that of smoking or alcoholism.

Two caveats matter. The original participants were all men, and the data are observational, so they show strong associations rather than proof of cause. Still, if your definition of success leaves no room for the people you care about, it ignores the factor this study kept coming back to.

Money matters, just not the way the scoreboard says

None of this means money is irrelevant. A widely cited 2010 study by Daniel Kahneman and Angus Deaton suggested that day-to-day emotional well-being in the US stopped improving beyond an income of about $75,000 a year. In 2023, Kahneman joined Matthew Killingsworth, whose data had pointed the other way, and Barbara Mellers to resolve the conflict in the journal PNAS.

Their reanalysis found that for most people, happiness kept rising with income. The plateau appeared only among the least happy 15 to 20 percent, whose happiness levelled off above roughly $100,000. In other words, more money tends to help, but it cannot fix everything, and it is not the same thing as a good life.

The more useful question is what your money is for. That is where the idea of enough comes in: the point at which extra income buys you less of what matters than the time and energy it costs to earn. If you want to explore that side in depth, start with what financial freedom means to you.

What people regret, and why to read it carefully

Bronnie Ware spent several years caring for people in the last weeks of their lives and wrote about what they told her, first in a blog post and then in her 2011 book The Top Five Regrets of the Dying. The regret she heard most often was the wish to have had "the courage to live a life true to myself", rather than the life others expected. The others: not working so hard, expressing feelings more openly, staying in touch with friends and letting themselves be happier.

Treat these as reflections, not data. They come from one carer's memory of the people she happened to look after, retold years later, with no sample and no method. What makes them worth reading is that they rhyme with the Harvard findings: at the end, relationships and living by your own values seem to matter more than titles or possessions. Use them as a prompt for your own thinking, not as proof.

Define success in five areas

A personal definition becomes useful when it is concrete. Work through five areas and, for each one, answer two questions: what do I want here, and what would be enough? The table shows the kind of answers that work: specific, observable and written in your own words.

AreaQuestion to answerExample answer
WorkWhat do I want to be known for, and how much work is enough?Projects I choose, four focused days a week
MoneyWhat does my life really cost, and what would feel secure?Fixed costs covered and six months of reserves
HealthWhat do I want my body to manage at 70?Hiking all day and carrying my own luggage
RelationshipsWho do I want to see every week, and who have I lost touch with?Dinner with close friends twice a month
TimeHow many hours a week should be fully mine?Two free evenings without screens or email

Illustrative answers for a hypothetical reader, not recommendations.

Time deserves its own line because it is the resource the borrowed scoreboard most often ignores. The idea of time affluence explains why feeling rich in time can matter as much as being rich in money.

Write your one-page definition

Give yourself an hour and a single sheet of paper. One page is enough to be specific and short enough to reread whenever a big choice comes up.

  1. Write one or two sentences for each of the five areas, in the present tense, as if you were already living them.
  2. Read each sentence and ask whose voice it is. If it sounds like a parent, an employer or a social media feed, rewrite it or cross it out.
  3. Add what enough looks like: a number, a frequency or a sign you could observe.
  4. Name one conflict between areas, for example income versus time, and decide which one wins for the next twelve months.
  5. Keep the page somewhere you will see it and review it every three months.

Expect the first draft to feel awkward. You are replacing a definition you absorbed over decades, and that takes more than one sitting. For a longer horizon, the methods in life design help you turn the page into several possible futures and test them in small steps.

You can win a game you never chose and still feel that you have lost.

Success, defined well, is less a finish line than a set of conditions you keep returning to: people you are close to, work that feels like yours, money that serves a purpose and time you can call your own. Write it down, and the next big decision gets easier, because you know what you are deciding for.

Sources

  1. Over nearly 80 years, Harvard study has been showing how to live a healthy and happy life, Harvard Gazette, 2017
  2. Harvard Study of Adult Development, official website
  3. Income and emotional well-being: A conflict resolved, Killingsworth, Kahneman and Mellers, PNAS, 2023
  4. Regrets of the Dying, Bronnie Ware

Questions and answers

Good to know

Is it selfish to define success for yourself?

Not usually. A personal definition often includes other people more, not less, because relationships tend to rise to the top once you stop measuring yourself against outside benchmarks. It simply means you decide what counts instead of inheriting the rules.

What does the Harvard Study of Adult Development actually show?

It shows that, over decades of follow-up, people with warmer and more satisfying relationships tended to be healthier and happier later in life. Because it is observational and the original participants were all men, it shows strong associations rather than proof of cause.

Does more money make people happier?

A 2023 reanalysis in PNAS found that for most people in the US, happiness kept rising with income, and it levelled off only for the least happy group. Money helps, but how you use it and what it costs you to earn it matter as much as the amount.

How often should I revisit my definition?

A short review every three months works well, with a deeper rewrite after big changes such as a new job, a move or a new family member. The aim is a definition that grows with you, not a contract you have to honour forever.

The trevisia letter. One idea, one number, one next step.

Subscribe

Keep reading

More from Success & Mindset